Did you enjoy it?

Well did you enjoy it, please answer truthfully.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Here on behalf of the Bookworm Blog

No, not really.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Keep going, friend :D! I believe in you!

 

#ProtectThePuddle

 

#WinterProtectionSquad

 

#EmbraceTheDanger

 

'Goat like yelps'

-Hootsie

 

#DugongProject

SOCKISM

 I've done so much wrong

#UniquaIsAUniqua

 I'm so sorry.

Basic psychology. Also I read a lot of memes.

Quite a few parts were disappointing, to say the least

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 

~Corey~

 

-Morrigan-

 

/Leonel/

 

Board Game Designer

 

WINTERWATCHER

TURTLEWAFFLE

CLERILISAFRUIT

 

 ~Joined 2015~

 

#RememberTheLost

#FISHAreFriends4LIFE

#StayPeculiar

 

Slytherin

IceWing

CREW!!!!

Wizard

Avenger

Peculiar

Forum Maintenance Worker

 

 

I LOVED IT! I probably could have loved it a little more if WinterWatcher happened, BUT I STILL LOVE IT

 

Oooooh, you has a bookworm blog? That's super cool! ;3

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

~DerpSloth~

 

There's a million things I haven't done...

 

{She/Her/Weirdo}

Proud Christian

Certified Meme

 

..Just you wait!

 

#Hamiltrash

#Equal

You are wonderful, and don't you forget it! :3 Happy holidays!

Truthfully, not really. It seemed kind of like Winter was just entirely tossed aside, and all of the sudden didn't like Moon anymore....

-is restraining herself from typing everything she thinks is wrong with DoD-

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Sea Heart

 

Maybe I'm not what seem. It doesn't mean won't still be there for you.

 

O come, O come Emma-a-a-neul

 

I'll deck my halls with boughs of holly, but I'm not feeling quite jolly.

@Sea Heart: EXACTLY. Did you also notice how Moon's personality also changed? 

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

~{I am STORMYSKIES}~

Respect my opinion, I'll respect yours

   [#Authoress in training] [#CharaDefenseSquad]

        [#GTLive][#Equality][#RememberTheLost]

 

majority say they didn't like it as of now

 

and i am part of that majority

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 ~Eos~

A NightWing

A Hufflepuff

A BYU Cougar

A Makar

A Smedry

A Conqueror 

An Asexual

#I'mAnAbioticFactor

 My OCs? There's to many to list here

#SPOOPY4EVA

 

 

 

I liked the story, I just didn't like the characters. Moon felt more like a Mary Sue then usual, and Winter was too grumpy after what happened in WT.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

~Thunderstorm~

Or just Thunder or TS

(She/her/they)

Queen of winged cats

 

“It’s out there, somewhere in the woods, waiting.”

 

“Oh, just your friendly neighborhood brown tabby antagonist.” ~Winter

 

Merry Christmas!

 

 

 

Yeah, I felt like everyone's personal character arcs were tossed aside for Qibli's.


Turtle's story about learning to stand up and be a hero? Gone. Winter's arc on changing and growing? Dead. Moon being y'know, a good character? Trashed.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Keep going, friend :D! I believe in you!

 

#ProtectThePuddle

 

#WinterProtectionSquad

 

#EmbraceTheDanger

 

'Goat like yelps'

-Hootsie

 

#DugongProject

SOCKISM

 I've done so much wrong

#UniquaIsAUniqua

 I'm so sorry.

Basic psychology. Also I read a lot of memes.

Warning: May start saying everything she thinks is wrong with DoD. It is wise to be prepared.

 

Yes, and Winter had a DRASTIC change in personality. Sure, he was under Darkstallers spell, but even after he was free, he seemed nothing like he was in WT.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Sea Heart

 

Maybe I'm not what seem. It doesn't mean won't still be there for you.

 

O come, O come Emma-a-a-neul

 

I'll deck my halls with boughs of holly, but I'm not feeling quite jolly.

It was kinda anticlimactic in more ways than one. Darkstalker's resolution was disappointing and Winterwatcher was the only real option in my opinion. Excited for book 11 though. 

 

But ANEMARIN YES

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

bye blue

I agree entirely and whole-heartedly with Sea Heart

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Keep going, friend :D! I believe in you!

 

#ProtectThePuddle

 

#WinterProtectionSquad

 

#EmbraceTheDanger

 

'Goat like yelps'

-Hootsie

 

#DugongProject

SOCKISM

 I've done so much wrong

#UniquaIsAUniqua

 I'm so sorry.

Basic psychology. Also I read a lot of memes.

After knowing that Moonbli is canon, and how DoD is, I support Winterwatcher even more than usual. It feels like the drastic changes for personality were JUST so that Moonbli happened, when it had seemed (at least to me) that Winterwatcher was going to be it. I'm only looking forward to book eleven to learn about the new tribes, since it seems just Qibli and Odd Moon are going to be PoVing for the third arc. I was hoping Tui would get characters like Kinkajou and Anenome in there, so that we could hear their PoVs in the third arc. But no. As far as we know, it's just going to be Odd Moon and Qibli.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Sea Heart

 

Maybe I'm not what seem. It doesn't mean won't still be there for you.

 

O come, O come Emma-a-a-neul

 

I'll deck my halls with boughs of holly, but I'm not feeling quite jolly.

I agree, Winter, Moon, and Qibli were all drastically warped so that Moonbli could happen. The longer book was just so they could stuff in awkward 'moments'

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Keep going, friend :D! I believe in you!

 

#ProtectThePuddle

 

#WinterProtectionSquad

 

#EmbraceTheDanger

 

'Goat like yelps'

-Hootsie

 

#DugongProject

SOCKISM

 I've done so much wrong

#UniquaIsAUniqua

 I'm so sorry.

Basic psychology. Also I read a lot of memes.

I think that DoD's epilogue was kind of a letdown. How could Winter just not care about Moon anymore? Did he hear Moon and Qibli talking about how they love each other?

 

Also, I agree with all of you. Moon WAS acting really weird, and out of character. She got angry and yelled because Darkstalker wasn't evil to her. That's not Moon.

 

Overall, I loved to book, and want to see eleven!

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Winter

-Queen of Warrior Cats-

 

 

Deck the halls with boughs of holly, fa la la la la la la la la

 

I am the Forum Twigkit

 

 

“Oh, just your friendly neighborhood brown tabby antagonist!”

 

 

 

 

 

                

@Ghost and Sea Heart: We need to make a thread about how many characters were destroyed in this book.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

~{I am STORMYSKIES}~

Respect my opinion, I'll respect yours

   [#Authoress in training] [#CharaDefenseSquad]

        [#GTLive][#Equality][#RememberTheLost]

 

No, we need to make a thread about everything we think is wrong with DoD...

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Sea Heart

 

Maybe I'm not what seem. It doesn't mean won't still be there for you.

 

O come, O come Emma-a-a-neul

 

I'll deck my halls with boughs of holly, but I'm not feeling quite jolly.

Yeah, that's a better idea :P

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

~{I am STORMYSKIES}~

Respect my opinion, I'll respect yours

   [#Authoress in training] [#CharaDefenseSquad]

        [#GTLive][#Equality][#RememberTheLost]

 

Can i join your thread of everything we think is wrong with DoD?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 ~Eos~

A NightWing

A Hufflepuff

A BYU Cougar

A Makar

A Smedry

A Conqueror 

An Asexual

#I'mAnAbioticFactor

 My OCs? There's to many to list here

#SPOOPY4EVA

 

 

 

honestly, I thought it did pretty well for a book with such high expectations and a fanbase that can be hard to please. 

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

:・゚☆✧ marx :・゚☆✧

✧ queen of glitter

✧ forum novakid/xurkitree 

✧ PRAISE SOCKS

✧ MINTY FRESH PEBBLES

 

 

of course I enjoyed it how often do you think I get to read a good new book

I mean

some of it didn't make sense

and I realllllly want a lot of what happened to be explained to me in detail

and yes, it did feel like the characters kinda suddenly were acting a bit... off, but hey they're Tui's characters she can do what she wants with them right

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Kit Syzygy

 

Spooky Queen of Rabbits & Eldritch Things

 

hi I like space & spooky stuff

 

R.I.P.

Bucky

 

"Daylight dies

Blackout the sky

Does anyone care?

Is anybody there?"

@Ghost, Sea Heart, and Stormyskies 

 

may i be a part of the thread of what's wrong with DoD

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

 ~Eos~

A NightWing

A Hufflepuff

A BYU Cougar

A Makar

A Smedry

A Conqueror 

An Asexual

#I'mAnAbioticFactor

 My OCs? There's to many to list here

#SPOOPY4EVA

 

 

 

Ooh! May I be a part of your thread?

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

Winter

-Queen of Warrior Cats-

 

 

Deck the halls with boughs of holly, fa la la la la la la la la

 

I am the Forum Twigkit

 

 

“Oh, just your friendly neighborhood brown tabby antagonist!”

 

 

 

 

 

                

@Eos: Of course! It's not like it's just for us three.

  • Posted at:

Please tell us why you'd like to report this post

~{I am STORMYSKIES}~

Respect my opinion, I'll respect yours

   [#Authoress in training] [#CharaDefenseSquad]

        [#GTLive][#Equality][#RememberTheLost]