I was originally going to list reasons and stuff, but I'm a little discouraged, so here are the winners:
(If an area has asterisks around it, this area has been added to the original, if there are brackets around it, it has been edited, if something you put in your form is missing, then it was removed.)
Mothkit winner: Wild
Age: 4 moons
Appearance: Mothkit is a semi-fluffy white tom with large ears, dark green eyes with fur that feels fuzzy, and he has fluffy, tufted paws. He has a bushy tail, and he is rather small for his age.
Personality: Mothkit is curious, always getting into some sort of mischief unintentionally; he's quiet and introverted, and some cats joke that he's the reincarnation of Moth Flight (even though he isn't) since they're so similar. He loves sneaking out of camp and seeing the world.
Backstory: At his birth, Mothkit's mother caught sight of a fuzzy moth (a Venezuelan Poodle Moth) in front of the Nursery. Drawing similarities from her youngest son and the moth, his mother named him Mothkit.
Bearpaw winner: Midsummer
Appearance: Bearpaw is a large brown tom with a stubby tail and short legs. He has dark green eyes with a scar under his left one. His fur is very long and tangly with many burrs stuck in it. The tips of his ears are black.
Personality: Bearpaw is boisterous and loud. He loves causing trouble and creating a racket. He thinks hunting is boring and he'd much rather do battle practice. He hopes no one knows it, but he has a soft spot for elder stories. He always pretends not to listen, but he always is. He agrees that ThunderClan is way to bossy and ShadowClan is best.
Mousestar winner: Leopard
Age: 58 moons
Appearance: Small, dark grayish-brown tabby cat, large ears, long tail
Personality: Mousestar is a proud leader and a good fighter. She is loyal to her Clan to her last breath and would do anything to defend it. She always tries to make good choices for her Clan and often will consult with every cat in the Clan before she makes a decision.
Backstory: Mousestar grew up always wanting to help and serve her Clan in any way she could. She'd always be volunteering for extra patrols and hunting, and helped out with any other job she could. She defended the Clan bravely, and after the previous deputy died in a battle (despite all her efforts to save him [which wasn't as much, because she was also badly injured]), she was made deputy, and eventually, leader.
Harepuddle winner: Leopard
Age: 23 moons
Appearance: Dark gray, rather large, tom
Personality: Harepuddle doesn't prefer to speak out, staying at the back of the crowd and being ordered around. He's usually pretty subdued, and doesn't care to have authority, and has never had an apprentice. (Technically.) He works hard for the good of his Clan.
Backstory: He was given an apprentice, but his lack of authority over her/not wanting to have authority over her resulted in him not training her well. One afternoon, (soon after he was given an apprentice) his apprentice was hunting in the woods near the ShadowClan border and accidentally chased a rabbit across it because she wasn't sure where it was and didn't notice the scent marks. A ShadowClan patrol found her, and although a RiverClan patrol showed up in time, she was killed in the battle.
Briarspiral winner: Leopard
Age: 30 moons
Role: Medicine cat
Appearance: Dark brown tabby
Personality: Briarspiral is a kind, sweet, and gentle cat. She likes to take care of others, and has a good memory, but isn't good at hunting or fighting. She is a skilled medicine cat and respected in all the Clans.
Backstory: *Briarspiral was born into a litter of two, with her brother, Pinedust.* As a kit, Briarspiral made friends with the medicine cat and would sometimes help her treat basic injuries, since that medicine cat didn't have an apprentice yet. She was apprenticed regualarly, but had a lot of trouble with learning to hunt and fight, and began to use the medicine cat's den and helping out around there as a safe place away from her regular training. It was eventually decided that she should train to be a medicine cat instead, and she was apprenticed to the medicine cat.
Pinedust winner: Sorrel
Age: 24-ish moons.
Appearance: a dark brown tom with lighter brown muzzle, tail, and paws. Green eyes.
Personality: is usually quite shy and reserved, but can be kind and smart and loving when you get to know him.
Backstory: born into a litter of two, sister is BriarSpiral, a medicine cat. His mother is currently an elder. He decided to be a warrior, to help defend his clan. His mentor taught him well as an apprentice, and soon PineDust got his warrior name... And fell in love with a RiverClan cat named [Beaverspring]. He's been meeting her every night for 3 moons, and now she's expecting his kits...
Beaverspring winner: Leopard
Age: 19 moons
Appearance: Plain brown fur, blue eyes, white tips of ears
Personality: Beaverspring is also a kind, gentle cat, always supporting you with a kind word, advice, or some help. She's a skilled hunter.
Backstory: Pretty much the same as Pinedust, they love each other [and have been meeting each other every night]. *Beaverspring is now expecting their kits.*